Gift box
GSM Performance Customer Car Colouring Book Edition 1
Mechanical Vs Electrical Fire Extinguishers: What Is The Difference And Which To Choose?
Fire extinguisher guide
A plumbed-in fire extinguisher system is a bottle fixed in the car, piped to nozzles that point into the cockpit and the engine bay. When it is fired, it floods those areas with extinguishant. The big choice when you buy one is how it is fired: by a pull cable, which is a mechanical system, or by a switch, which is an electrical system.
Both work well when they are fitted and maintained properly. This guide explains how each one works, what fitting involves, the FIA lists they appear on, and how we would choose between them.
- Mechanical systems fire from a pull cable; electrical systems fire from a switch
- Both types need a driver trigger inside and an external trigger for marshals
- Both come in versions on FIA Technical List 16, and some electrical systems are on Technical List 52 (FIA 8865-2015)
- The mechanical version of the same OMP or Sparco system costs less than the electrical one
- Neither type is maintenance free, and both need servicing to the maker's schedule
- Your championship's rules decide what you need, so read them first
What is on this page
How each type fires
A mechanical system has a valve on the bottle with a lever. A steel cable runs from that lever to a pull handle in the cockpit, and a second cable runs to an external handle, usually near the circuit breaker. Pulling either handle opens the valve and the bottle discharges through the pipes and nozzles. Nothing about it depends on the car’s electrics.
An electrical system replaces the cables with wiring. A control unit sits between a button in the cockpit, an external button for the marshals and an electrically fired valve on the bottle. The control unit has its own power source or a specified supply, depending on the system, and a test indicator lets you check the circuit without discharging the bottle.
On either type, the driver must be able to fire the system while sitting in the seat with the harness done up and the steering wheel on. The external trigger has to be marked so a marshal can find it quickly.
The extinguishant is the same whichever way it is fired. The OMP SST systems, for example, use a clean gas agent (FK-5-1-12) that leaves no residue and does not conduct electricity.
What fitting involves
With a mechanical system, the work is in the cables. Plan where the internal and external handles will go and how the cables will run before you drill any bottle mounts. Keep to the minimum bend radius in the instructions, because tight bends add friction and can stop the valve moving through its full travel. Support the outer cable along its length and keep it away from heat and sharp edges.
An electrical system is usually tidier to route, because wiring bends more easily than a cable. The trade-off is that the control unit, switches and wiring all have to be fitted, armed and checked properly. Use the switches supplied with the kit: a generic dash button may not give the guarded or momentary action the system needs.
Garreth’s advice for either type is to fit it as the instructions say, and not to improvise with parts from another kit.
FIA approvals
The FIA keeps lists of homologated systems. Technical List 16 covers plumbed-in systems approved to the older 1999 standard. Technical List 52 covers systems approved to FIA 8865-2015, the newer standard. They are not interchangeable, so a system on List 16 does not meet a rule that asks for 8865-2015.
Mechanical and electrical systems both appear on List 16. The 8865-2015 systems we list, such as the Sparco 8865 and the OMP CESAL4, are electrical. Our guide to FIA fire extinguisher homologations goes through the lists in detail.
| Mechanical | Electrical | |
|---|---|---|
| How it fires | Pull cable to a lever on the valve | Switch, control unit and wiring |
| Relies on power | No | Yes, its own source or a specified supply |
| Fitting | Cable routing and bend radius matter most | Tidier routing; unit and switches must be armed and checked |
| Checks | Handle travel and cable condition | Test indicator, without discharging |
| FIA lists | Technical List 16 | Technical List 16 or List 52 (8865-2015) |
| Cost | Lower for the same bottle | Higher for the same bottle |
Cost and servicing
Across the OMP and Sparco systems we list, the mechanical version of a system costs less than the electrical version with the same bottle. The difference is the control unit, switches and wiring.
Neither type looks after itself. Mechanical cables can corrode, kink or work loose, so check the handle moves the valve through its full travel. Electrical systems need their test checked to the maker’s schedule. Both need servicing by the manufacturer or an appointed agent, with the service markings kept legible. Our guide to servicing a motorsport fire extinguisher covers where to send it.
Which one to choose
Start with the rules. There is no single requirement for every competition car: it depends on the discipline, the class and the event, so read the current regulation that applies to your car. If it asks for FIA 8865-2015, that narrows the choice to a List 52 system straight away.
If the rules allow either, a mechanical system is simpler and costs less, and it suits a car with basic electrics or a historic car. An electrical system suits a car where the cable run would be long or awkward, or where the build already has a neat, well-planned wiring loom.
-
From £2,762.40 Incl. VATPayPal CreditKlarna ReadySelect options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
What is the difference between a mechanical and an electrical fire extinguisher?
A mechanical system fires from a pull cable, and an electrical system fires from a switch through a control unit and wiring.
Does an electrical fire extinguisher need the car's battery?
It needs a power supply, which is either the system’s own source or a specified supply, depending on the system.
Is Technical List 16 the same as FIA 8865-2015?
No. List 16 covers the older 1999 standard and List 52 covers FIA 8865-2015, and they are not interchangeable.
Is a mechanical fire extinguisher cheaper?
Yes. Across the OMP and Sparco systems we list, the mechanical version costs less than the electrical one with the same bottle.
Can I test a fire extinguisher system by firing it?
No. Use the non-discharge checks and service schedule from the maker, and never test by discharging the bottle.
Check which FIA list your championship asks for, then choose the system you can fit and check properly.
Tell us the car and the championship, and we will help you find a system that matches the rules.
